In the August issue of this ezine, I ran a little competition in which I invited readers to send me their favorite must-not-do or 'Cardinal Sin' related to hydraulics.
Several hundred members submitted entries and I've edited and compiled them all into one, succinct document, titled:
132 'Cardinal Sins' of Hydraulics ... What NOT To Do With Hydraulic Equipment.
As an incentive, and to make it a bit of fun, I announced that the 10 entries I judged
to be the best would receive as a prize; a copy of my new children's picture story book:
Farmer Mick Harvest Time Havoc (for those of you who are curious,
you can check it out here).
Judging the winners was no easy task. Because as the final document shows, there were a LOT of good entries. But here are my top 10. Your favorites may differ and that's fine, but as is the norm in these things, the judge's decision is final and no correspondence will be entered into.
Oh, and perhaps not surprisingly, some of the more common 'sins' were sent in by more than one contestant. So if do you see something mentioned below that you sent in yourself, the guy in the winner's circle either got in first or said it better.
So with that in mind here are the winners, in no particular order:
The corporate award goes to Case New Holland (CNH). The guys at CNH must pay attention to their hydraulics because I received multiple entries from their various locations around the world. Truman Lomi who works for CNH, Sydney Australia scores for this one:
"Condemning a hydraulic component as faulty without proving it through a logical process of elimination."
If you employ people to work on hydraulic equipment and you do nothing else but drum this one into their head, you will save yourself a small fortune.
Truman's colleague at CNH Burr Ridge Illinois USA, Bruce Arndt, also makes the top ten with this no-no:
"Not ensuring all accumulators are completely discharged prior to commencing work on a system."
This should be obvious but isn't always to the uninitiated. A mechanical equivalent is trying to
disassemble a spring-applied air brake without considering the potential energy of the
compressed spring - which you can't see - you have to know it's there and take the necessary precautions.
Kudos to Kevin McCaffrey and his team at Excel Hydraulics, Sydney Australia. They did a brainstorming session around this and came up with many good submissions. But this 'sin' stood out for me:
"Measuring o-rings for replacement purposes (it's the grooves you should be measuring)."
This may seem harmless enough on the surface, but the upshot of it is it often results in the wrong seals being installed. And this can cause a lot of heartache.
continued below ...
The Nice Things People Say ...
"The knowledge I've gained from this information has been
so valuable it has earned me a raise!"
Find out more ...
Heavy Equipment Mechanic
My top 10 'Cardinal Sins', continued|
continued from above…
Sylvain Roy who works for Trican Well Service, Red Deer Canada, nailed this common mistake which gets a lot of inexperienced circuit designers into bother:
"Believing piloted operated check valves are motion control valves - and that counterbalance valves are load holding valves."
The best 'Cardinal Sins' cut to the quick. Like this one sent in by Sebastien Gagnon, from Equipements Anderson, Chesterville Canada:
"Allowing a hydraulic hose to twist when it's being tightened."
Stephen Brosnan, who works for the CSIRO in Brisbane Australia joins the winners list too with:
"Modifying the hydraulic (or electrical) circuit but not updating the schematics to reflect the changes."
There's nothing worse than trying to troubleshoot a complex hydraulic system with a drawing that's not accurate. And in the case of an electrical circuit, I remember once working with a battle weary electrician, troubleshooting a problem on an electro-hydraulic system, and as soon as he realized the drawing wasn't accurate he became very wary, stating: "That's how you get fried!"
Steve Cater of Freco Fluid Power, Nepean Canada makes the cut with:
"Replacing a component which has failed catastrophically without cleaning the tank and flushing the system."
Anybody who's worked in the hydraulic repair business knows anyone who commits this 'sin' causes a lot of weeping and gnashing of teeth.
Another 'Cardinal Sin' which really is the hallmark of a rank amateur, is this one submitted by Hendrik de Villiers from Bahrain:
"Applying silicone sealant to tank lids or o-rings."
And here's another trap for the uninformed, submitted by Michael Calverley who works for Baker Atlas in Algeria:
"Assuming the filter element is correct - just because it fits."
I committed this sin many years ago when young and inexperienced and only through sheer luck
did I avoid a very expensive disaster. It's rather a long story which I'll save for my
Hydraulics Pro Club members.
And finally, George Robertson from Fugro in Aberdeen Scotland summed up this whole exercise with:
"People who have been around hydraulics for years, who "know it all"
making the same mistakes again and again, and not taking the time to really understand
how hydraulics work."
When it comes to hydraulics, I don't think you ever know it all. There's always something to learn, AND there's always a deeper level of understanding to be had about the things you 'know'.
And if your name appears above, a special child on your Christmas (or other) gift list can be
ticked off. Because of copy of Farmer Mick Harvest Time Havoc will be on its way to you shortly.
If you are one of the winners named above, please send me an email with the mailing address you'd like the book shipped to.
"This book has the potential to save many
organizations lots of money. It should be on the bookshelf of every engineer, supervisor, planner and
technician who deals with hydraulic equipment... it's worth its weight in gold." Find out more
Alexander (Sandy) Dunn
Plant Maintenance Resource Center
How to synchronize hydraulic cylinders|
The problem of synchronizing multiple hydraulic cylinders arises in many applications.
This Instant Knowledge report introduces and explains eight different solutions to this problem. To assist
you in selecting the most suitable solution for your application, each method is considered
according to its level of accuracy, cost and complexity. The methods discussed
are applicable to any number and any type of hydraulic actuator.
Find out more
||Content for your web site or e-zine
Need some fresh content for your web site or e-zine?
You now have permission to reprint these 'Inside Hydraulics'
articles on your web site or in your e-zine, provided:
1. Each article is printed in its full form with no changes.
2. You send an e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org to advise us
where you'll be publishing them.
3. You include the following acknowledgement at the end of each article:
About the Author: Brendan Casey has more than 20 years
experience in the maintenance, repair and overhaul of
mobile and industrial hydraulic equipment. For more
information on reducing the operating cost and increasing
the uptime of your hydraulic equipment, visit his
web site: http://www.InsiderSecretsToHydraulics.com
||Help us spread the word|
If you've found our 'Inside Hydraulics' newsletter interesting
and informative, then chances are you have a colleague
who would too. Help spread the word about 'Inside Hydraulics' by forwarding this
issue to a colleague. If they share your interest in
hydraulics, then they will surely appreciate being told about this
New subscribers can get the newsletter by completing the form at
||Tell us what you think|
We would love to hear what you
think of this issue of our 'Inside Hydraulics' newsletter. And of course, if you have any
suggestions for future issues, please send us those too.
Just e-mail the
editor at: email@example.com